Before I was even enrolled at a university, I had heard
countless stereotypes about college. My friends’ older siblings told us
wide-eyed high schoolers about the crazy parties, casual sex, and freedom
living on your own. We believed every word; we were so excited to not have a
curfew and explore our independence during college. What is the truth behind
hook-up culture in college? Is casual sex all that it’s made out to be in
movies, TV shows, and from crazy stories told by older friends? After
interviewing two individuals about casual sex in college and digging into
current research, it became even more clear that casual sex is not all that our
older friends described it to be; there is a wide variety of reasoning and
motivations behind college students engaging in casual sex with others.
I chose to talk to two students: one who engages in casual
sex and one who does not. The student who does not engage in casual sex listed
a few reasons as to why she finds the culture harmful for students, especially
young women.
“I personally want to
engage in any sort of sexual behavior with someone that I really trust and
love,” she explained. “I feel like
as a heterosexual, college-aged woman, casual sex can really only lead to
heartbreak.” She revealed that learning about the emotional attachment that
women can associate with sex worried her about hooking up with someone that she
did not truly care about. Hook-up culture also seemed dangerous to her, as
casual sex could lead to sexually transmitted infections or unplanned
pregnancy. Lastly, she noted that there is a stigma and double standard between
men and women regarding casual sex. Women are often perceived as promiscuous
and portrayed negatively, whereas men are praised for sexual endeavors,
especially in college.
The student who chooses to participate in casual sex
portrayed hook-up culture in a more empowering manner. She described her
experiences with hook-ups in college as positive because she made the decision
to engage in sexual behaviors with her partners and felt as though she had the
freedom to do so. She mentioned that “casual
sex is only harmful if two partners’ intentions do not match up”, one example
being if one partner wants to pursue an exclusive relationship and the other
does not. Because she uses open communication before and after casual sex, she
said that the worries of casual sex usually do not cross her mind. She is not
afraid to discuss STIs or using contraceptives, and she admitted that casual
sex might not be as enjoyable without this aspect of open communication.
What does research tell us about casual sex? First, a study
conducted with college students revealed that almost an exact number of men and
women reported having casual sex in the past year1. However, the
study examined the factors that might go into a college hook-up including
alcohol, attachment, emotional reactions, religiosity, and family environment1.
The study found that the majority of women in their study did not have a
positive attitude about hooking up because of feeling let down or having too
high of expectations, and many women expressed that their peers had negative
attitudes towards women who were consistently having casual sex1.
Also, students who had an insecure attachment style often had fewer positive
encounters with casual sex, as their emotional and security needs were not met
by their partner1. Men reported higher rates of positive
psychological experiences, as well as students who had not considered peer
stereotypes and negative emotions surrounding casual sex1.
Another study indicated attachment styles are the most
important aspect of a college hook-up; the psychosocial factors associated with
casual sexual encounters were more obvious in those with anxious or avoidant
attachment styles2. Participants in the study who showed signs of
insecure attachment displayed symptoms of distress and consumed higher amounts
of alcohol before, during, and after hook-ups2. However, the main
conclusions around college hook-up culture were surrounding the commonality
between college students. All college students have similar risk and protective
factors surrounding hook-ups, between religiosity, alcohol, attachment style,
and depressive symptoms2.
All in all, choosing to participate in hook-up culture
should be entirely based on individual decision. However, a person’s attachment
style and risk and protective factors surrounding a sexual encounter can
greatly impact a hook-up. College students are participating in casual sex, but
the psychological impacts of casual sex vary based on attachment style and
previous attitudes in sex. There is clearly no right or wrong way to engage (or
not engage) in casual sex, proven by the research studies above. Casual sex may
not be for everyone, but there is value in learning about the trends and
educating yourself on the implications of casual sex, even if you are
personally not engaging in it.
1Owen, J., Rhoades, G., Stanley, S., and Fincham,
F. (2010). “Hooking up” among college students: Demographic and psychosocial
correlates. Archives of Sexual Behavior,
39(3), 653-663.
2Manthos, M., Owen, J., and Fincham, F. D.
(2014). A new perspective on hooking up among college students: Sexual behavior
as a function of distinct groups. Journal
of Social & Personal Relationships, 31(6), 815-829.