Romcoms. Some people love them, some people hate them. These movies depict idealistic scenarios about love and passion for us movie watchers to sit and spend 90 minutes either dreaming of or gagging about. I personally would rather not watch romcoms, however, my mom and sisters could spend all weekend binging them. They see a genuine love story, where I see nothing but a falsified wishful thinking plotline.
A study done by Veronica Hefner (2019) looked at romantic comedy content and there are 4 common themes in romcoms 1) the idealization of others (perfect partner) 2) soul mate/one and only 3) love at first sight and 4) love conquers all. Curious about what the people in my life, other than my romcom crazed sisters, thought about romcoms, I asked a friend their thoughts on romcoms.
They aren't my go to choice of movies, but I also don't mind watching them. I think that they are cute and “feel-goody”. I’ve watched them before as a pick-me-up. I do think they can get sappy, but it doesn't hurt to disappear in that kind of fantasy world for a little bit either.
I then told her about the 4 common themes that Hefner found and asked her whether or not she thinks those themes are applicable to real life.
Ummm, let's see. I definitely don't think love at first sight is a real thing. I just don't think you can truly love someone just by looking at them, you need to know them. I would say that soul mates do exist, but I again don't think we find them on the first try. I do agree with the idealization of others in the terms that some people are truly perfect for one another and make each other better. And I don't think love conquers all, like at all. I think it is hard work and dedication to a relationship that makes it seem like they can conquer anything, but the love itself isn't enough.
So my friend went about 50/50 on whether or not Hefner's common themes are actually true in real life.
Are they realistic? No, not really. But are they fun to watch and daydream about those types of situations? Yes, yes they are.
Hefner also talked about how watching these moves could shift one's life satisfaction, as they can make individuals happy and excited for future romance, or bummed and gloomy about them too. The study did not seem to find any significant differences in the effect that romcoms had on individuals with different attachment styles. They found that only the variables of gender, relationship status, and the type of romcom had an effect on the endorsement of life satisfaction (Hefner, 2019). To my surprise, males and partnered individuals reported higher life satisfaction after watching romcoms than females and single individuals. I was expecting it to be women that had higher satisfaction, and men to not feed into it quite as much.
So, what do you think about romcoms? Do you think that Hefner's 4 themes of romcoms are true in real life? Does watching them make you feel warm and fuzzy, or sick to the stomach? Let me know in the comments what you think about these movies and maybe drop your go to romcom!
Reference
Hefner, V. (2019). Does Love conquer all? an experiment testing the association between types of romantic comedy content and reports of romantic beliefs and life satisfaction. Psychology of Popular Media Culture, 8(4), 376–384. https://doi.org/10.1037/ppm0000201